Top-notch feedback. Thank you, Philippe!
I have just commented on then closed (without merging) a suggestion I received from @severo; I have no idea if he received my comment (in which I explained why I was closing w/o merging). (Fortunately we have a back channel so, no harm done).
Yes, I received two mails: “Fil commented…” and “Fil (@fil) has closed a suggestion…”. But I understand the problem is that you didn’t have that feedback in the interface.
I generally like the idea. (Great work folks!)
It seems to work well for typo fixes, minor suggestions, etc., which is probably the primary goal.
I do wonder a bit though about how future-accessible the comment discussions will be. Seems like it might still be best to handle more major feedback/collaboration out of band (e.g. on this forum or email).
I don’t see how I can reply to a suggestion? Someone has suggested changed to my notebook, but I actually forked someone else’s notebook and I and to communicate this to the suggester. I don’t see how to do this.
The easiest way would be to comment on the suggestion directly, like so (before closing it):
Does that help?
Yes, it does. thanks